Small-angle X-ray scattering study of photosystem i - detergent complexes: Implications for membrane protein crystallization

Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) was used to investigate the structure of isolated photosystem I (PSI) complexes stabilized in detergent solution. Two different types of PSI preparation were investigated. In the first preparation, thylakoid membranes were solubilized with Triton X100 and purified by density gradient centrifugation. SAXS data indicated large scattering objects or microphases that can be described as sheets with ∼68 Å thickness and a virtually infinite lateral extension. The observed thickness agreed well with the dimension of a PSI molecule across the thylakoid membrane. In the second preparation, PSI was isolated as before but was further purified by anion exchange chromatography resulting in functional complexes consisting of single PSI units with attached surfactant as evidenced by the particle volume and gyration radius extracted from the SAXS data. Several approaches were used to model the solution conformation of the complex. Three different ellipsoidal modeling approaches, a uniform density ellipsoid of revolution, a triaxial solid ellipsoid, and a core-shell model, found extended structures with dimensions that were not consistent with the PSI crystal structure (Ben-Shem, A.; et al. Nature 2003, 426, 630-635). Additionally, the SAXS data could not be modeled using the crystal structure embedded in a disk of detergent. The final approach considered the possibility that protein was partially unfolded by the detergent. The data were modeled using a "beads-on-a-string" approach that describes detergent micelles associated with the unfolded polypeptide chains. This model reproduced the position and relative amplitude of a peak present in the SAXS data at 0.16 Å^-1 but was not consistent with the data at larger length scales. We conclude that the polypeptide subunits at the periphery of the PSI complex were partially unfolded and associated with detergent micelles while the catalytically active core of the PSI complex remained structurally intact. This interpretation of the solution structure of isolated PSI complexes has broader implications for the investigation of the interactions of detergents and protein, especially for crystallization studies.