Collective nature of phonon energies beyond harmonic oscillators

Phonon quasi-particles have been monumental in microscopically understanding thermodynamics and transport properties in condensed matter for decades. Phonons have one-to-one correspondence with harmonic eigenstates and their energies are often described by simple independent harmonic oscillator models. Higher order terms in the potential energy lead to interactions among them, resulting in finite lifetimes and frequency shifts, even in perfect crystals. However, increasing evidence including constant volume heat capacity violating the Dulong-Petit law suggests the need for re-evaluation of phonons as having independent harmonic energies. In this work, we explicitly examine inter-mode dependence of phonon energies of a prototypical crystal, silicon, through energy covariance calculations and demonstrate the concerted nature of phonon energies even at 300 K, questioning independent harmonic oscillator assumptions commonly used for phonon energy descriptions of thermodynamics and transport.