Assessment of the Performance of Hydrofluoroolefins, Hydrochlorofluoroolefins, and Halogen-Free Foam Blowing Agents in Cellular Plastic Foams

Oak Ridge National Laboratory has conducted a literature search to identify relevant information available on alternative materials and technologies that are proposed for foam blowing agents applications. For comparison, similar information was collected for available hydrofluorocarbons (HFC), hydrofluoroolefin (HFO), and hydrochlorofluoroolefins (HCFO) materials. The publicly available literature was analyzed and assessed for technical accuracy for each alternative, and a gap analysis was conducted to understand if additional studies are required to fully assess the viability of an alternative. In assessing these alternatives, this project focused on relevant performance and safety attributes. The performance attributes collected include insulation value per unit thickness, which impacts energy usage of buildings and insulated equipment such as refrigerators. We also assessed the impact of blowing agents on foam mechanical properties and flammability characteristics, and the ability of current processing equipment and techniques to utilize these alternatives. Diffusion of blowing agents through foam cells and its impact on foam aging was also examined. The applications covered in this study are spray foam, boardstock, panels, and appliances. Some of the most relevant findings are summarized below.