Additive manufacturing case study

Geothermal technologies include an extremely wide range of products required for well construction, completion, production, intervention and surface energy conversion activities. Many of these products are geometrically complex, require multi-step and highly specialized fabrication processes, and are expensive due to the low production numbers typically associated with the geothermal market. These challenges along with the high temperature demands of the geothermal environment have also hindered the adoption of many tools routinely used in the oil & gas industry. Recent advancements in Additive Manufacturing (AM) materials of construction, build volumes and part quality have transitioned the technology from primarily cosmetic prototyping applications to the point where AM can be used to make production parts, even for the most demanding applications. These improved AM capabilities along with the inherent ability of AM to produce complex parts and, in some cases, geometries that cannot be manufactured using conventional casting, machining and joining fabrication approaches motivate an exploration of its potential to positively impact geothermal well construction and operations technologies. Sandia National Labs collaborated with Oak Ridge National Laboratory on a case study examining additive manufacturing opportunities for Geothermal applications. The study focused on designing components with improved performance characteristics that cannot be fabricated conventionally. A rotor for a downhole motor was chosen based on the potential for improving its rotational dynamics. Topology optimization was used as a design method to reduce the rotational inertia of the part while preserving sufficient rotational stiffness to transmit the torque required for the drilling application. The optimization resulted in a nearly 50% reduction in polar moment of inertia while maintaining other desired performance characteristics. The design developed using the topology optimization approach was fabricated using additive manufacturing and cannot be fabricated conventionally. This paper will discuss the design approach, performance improvements and manufacturing methods used to produce the part.